Ticcitoby Stories

Male reader yippie! Ah yes, summer camp. The place your parents send you over the summer to prevent you from rotting in your room. It's all fun, except for the fact odd figures keep appearing in the corner of your eyes that only you seem to be able to see.

This will be a collection of one shots I have created for Toby. All of the following will have a prompt theme designated to each work. All works are created by me, but suggestions are welcomed.

Leah is a eleven year old girl with albino,everyone thinks she's a snow monster or a ghost at her orphanage. She thinks that she will never get adopted by someone until she hears a knock on her window one night

This will have documented encounters with the creepypastas, and this is ur choice to read, so its not my fault if/when something happens to you!! This will kinda be like an online journal just in case I lose mine. Good luck in this rabbit hole... -AL3X

what the title says y/n uses she/her pronouns if you prefer a y/n with they/them pronouns, I have another version of this story on my profile!

This is a Jennifer's Body inspired story that includes you- the creature x Toby! After a 'date' goes wrong and you end up as a sacrifice for a shitty band you... come back.

A story about two girls and their lives spent amongst unruly creatures of the night

The return of an old lover

Yummy, a cannibal pizza! m!Mc, a pizza place worker, has several disorders, but mostly known for his clean records despite his attitude. He speaks German as well as English, but he has many secrets. Today he won't be so clean anymore after a strange encounter with a man in a feminine mask, one with a frowning mask, and one with tourette's. m!Mc has a sickness. Something he had since birth, that has never been seen before. Why'd it rise when he met the masked men? And why do the masked men feel unsettled by m!mc? Also- I'm Austrian and I speak mostly German, so if I misspelled something, let me know please- English is not my first language!! 🥀✌️

This story is a love story about Jeff the killer and a male reader / OC. trigger warning : -blood mentioned -trauma mentioned -little sexual scenes -deaths -swear words -brutal descriptions (The picture on the cover is not mine)

... The fire continued cackling, yet the previously caged bird sang in laughter. Like a phoenix, she is reborn. ... Creepypasta various x reader

not taking this seriously at all, but was inspired by the multiple fics I've been reading. toby rodgers x reader, an angsty one at that x) It willll be a slow burn, also slow with updates cause I'm a busy lady. but give me a chanceee haven't interacted with this fandom or with creepypasta entirely since middle school, but noticed it trending online again. be nice to me and read my stupid little story I love you !

UR A SOOPER EDGY KILLER WHO IS MERCILESS AND BADASSS AND EVERYBODY LOVES HER BUT NOBODY KNOWS( BC UR SO BADASS) AND CREEPYPASTA AND CREEPY TREE MAN ARE LIKE "OH WOW" AND YOU LIVE IN THEIR MANSION AND THEN YEA AND THEN YOU GET TO CHOSE WHICH SOCIOPATH IS THE HOTTEST AND DATE THEM WHO WILL IT BE????

(Cover from HAHADIT)

A story about a girl who lives in Slenderman's mansion but she was hidden in the highest floor where noone stays at. Everyone was banned to enter that floor unless you are slenderman It was not her intention to hide but she needs though. she was called 𝓣𝓱𝓮 𝓢𝓲𝓵𝓮𝓷𝓽 𝓚𝓲𝓵𝓵𝓮𝓻 what happens when the other pasta's found out that there's a Hidden Empress living with them. Read and find out! Started at May 6, 2022 End: ???

They said Joyce Lin never hurt anyone. She was quiet, unreadable, and known for smiling only when angry. But after crossing her, people lost friends, secrets spread, and sleep became impossible. Then she disappeared. Now stories of a girl with dark eyes and a cold smile appear everywhere. They call her Ice Smile. And if she smiles at you... it's already too late. Some monsters are born. Others are made. Her smile doesn't kill you. The truth does. They feared her heartbeat. They should have feared her grin. A human entered the mansion. None of them left unchanged. Pinterest pics are not mine, credits to og owners!

When Y/N is forced from her home, she meets a dog. A smiling dog. A dangerous dog. A bloodied dog. Yet, even though this creature is a nightmare on four legs, it's helping her. Can Y/N survive his strange behavior and his Creepypasta comrades?

There was a time, where everything was normal. Unusual things never happened, so when they did, no one believed it. And as a result, a boy named Jeff suffered the consequences. I was naive enough to believe that everything was going to be okay. That everything was still completely normal, despite absolutely everything changing. Jeff was like an unpredictable tornado, whirling into my life with little regard that almost mimicked his little regard for life. He was an enigma; an anomaly stuck between the bridge of normalcy. An enigma that was hellbent on destroying the little left of life I had. The question is, will I allow him to succeed? (I do not own Jeff/any creepypasta characters mentioned. They belong to the original owners.)

─── ⋆⋅☆⋅⋆ ─── When a soaking figure appears in you apartment before vanishing impossibly quickly, trouble is sure to follow... ─── ⋆⋅☆⋅⋆ ─── NO USE OF Y/N ─── ⋆⋅☆⋅⋆ ─── This story is being slowly updated due to me being in the midst of my finals! Last updated: 18/4/26 ART AND COVER FONT IS MINE ─── ⋆⋅☆⋅⋆ ─── Gender Neutral Reader ─── ⋆⋅☆⋅⋆ ─── This story is a fanfic including the creepypasta, marble hornets and Slenderverse fandoms. I will do my best to not make the characters totally fanon, however I will have to deviate from their cannon selves in places (or they'd just kill you immediately). Also, as a Marble Hornets fan, I am aware that Masky and Hoodie are not proxies canonically. However, for the purpose of this story they will be. I will also be using characters from the series EverymanHYBRID- so if you don't know what this is then I recommend doing a quick search as parts of this story will be written under the assumption you understand what I'm referencing. The EverymanHYBRID channel and series is still up on YouTube but is fairly complex to understand (I'm talking from pure personal experience and hours of confusion myself) so I'd recommend Night Mind's series that explains the series in-depth (though even after watching it twice I'm still confused in places). ─── ⋆⋅☆⋅⋆ ─── TW: gore, violence, blood, toxic relationships, death, murder, bad language/cursing, unsettling descriptions, men being men, bodily damage, MAYBE implied NSFW (though nothing at all explicit) etc... there will NOT be a TW at the start of each chapter, so be warned! If any of these topics are triggering for you, please no not read.

THE RE-WRITE IS BEING RELEASED. THIS VERSION IS NO LONGER BEING UPDATED. ─── ⋆⋅☆⋅⋆ ─── When a soaking figure appears in Y/N's dorm before vanishing impossibly quickly, trouble is sure to follow... ─── ⋆⋅☆⋅⋆ ─── This story is being constantly updated! There will be new parts every two weeks (minimum). Last edited: 1/12/25 ART AND COVER FONT IS MINE ─── ⋆⋅☆⋅⋆ ─── Female Y/N ─── ⋆⋅☆⋅⋆ ─── This story is a fanfic including the creepypasta, marble hornets and Slenderverse fandoms. I will do my best to not make the characters totally fanon, however I will have to deviate from their cannon selves in places (or they'd just kill you immediately). Also, as a Marble Hornets fan, I am aware that Masky and Hoodie are not proxies canonically. However, for the purpose of this story they will be. I will also be using characters from the series EverymanHYBRID- so if you don't know what this is then I recommend doing a quick search as parts of this story will be written under the assumption you understand what I'm referencing. The EverymanHYBRID channel and series is still up on YouTube but is fairly complex to understand (I'm talking from pure personal experience and hours of confusion myself) so I'd recommend Night Mind's series that explains the series in-depth. ─── ⋆⋅☆⋅⋆ ─── TW: gore, violence, blood, toxic relationships, death, murder, bad language/cursing, unsettling/graphic descriptions, men being men, bodily damage, MAYBE implied NSFW (though nothing at all explicit), religious trauma, IMPLIED r4pe (NOTHING explicit) etc... there will NOT be a TW at the start of each chapter, so be warned! If any of these topics are triggering for you, please do not